A Primacy of Service: Reflections on the Anglican-Catholic Dialogue

“I find it daunting to realize how deeply this anthropology of the elite human has shaped Christian belief and practice,” said Johnson. “Not only has it prevented equality and justice in the human community, but with its conviction that humans are masters and rulers of nature, it opened the door to centuries of unbridled exploitation of nature without protest from the churches until very recently.”
—Elizabeth Johnson

It has become fashionable to denounce “anthropocentrism.” The term itself, especially in theological circles, names an uncritical privilege accorded to humanity, grounded in flat or literal readings of the opening chapters of Genesis, but more broadly a myopic way of reading the Bible as a story solely about humanity. Roman Catholics and Protestants alike have rallied to the defense of non-human creatures with apologies ranging from critical Biblical exegesis and appeals to saints like Francis to more systematic and philosophical treatments.[1] Many of these criticisms rightly exhort us to widen or reorient our theological framework of creation.

They challenge us to see humans as integrated parts of a complex system of creaturely being. Moreover, they are often motivated by and provide rich ethical reflection and discussion about the ramifications of human thought and behavior for other creatures. It is not uncommon, however, for theological criticisms of anthropocentrism to lack accounts of human vocation, activity, and creativity sufficiently constructive enough to counter the often unanticipated problems of anthropocentrism, especially those coming from non-theological quarters.[2]

Theologians in the Anglican and Roman Catholic traditions, especially in the twentieth century, have offered highly developed theological anthropologies, which, while possessing many resources to counter the uncritical and deleterious tendencies of anthropocentrism, have sadly been discarded as part of the “anthropocentric” Christian theological legacy. What follows proposes that an ecumenical rapprochement, in the spirit of unity in mission and “mutual learning,” offers resources for rethinking anthropocentrism, for re-articulating the role of humanity, namely in the natural world, in terms of a centrality of service, and for walking together as the Church in unexpected places and ways, namely in the often confusing and conflicted sphere of religion and science.[3]

I. The Status and Role of Humanity in the World

Permit a generalization: one characteristic of ecclesial and theological literature in the twentieth century is the attempt to wrestle with the shifting ethos of the time. The optimism toward human capacity for mastery in the late nineteenth century faded quickly with the Great War and the Great Depression to be eclipsed by duty—first, the duty to recover from the disasters of the war and economic depression; next, to address the needs of another war. People everywhere turned their talents in an unprecedented manner to the business of war. Wartime production led to scientific advancements. In the wake of WWII, these leaps changed the shape of life around the globe. Beyond medicine and technology, many hoped that the great scientific advances of the twentieth century would overcome existential, psychological, and spiritual problems.[4]

Theologians and people of the Church observed a wide-spread experience of disconnectedness, not only between institutional religion and the public square, but also a personal isolation. Walker Percy was adroit in diagnosing this malaise. In The Moviegoer, Percy’s character, Binx Bolling, muses, “I have discovered that most people have no one to talk to, no one, that is, who really wants to listen. When it does at last dawn on a man that you really want to hear about his business, the look that comes over his face is something to see.”[5] Binx attributes this condition to “scientific humanism,” which he defines as, “needs are satisfied, everyone becomes an anyone, a warm and creative person, and prospers like a dung beetle.” Living between the dread of annihilation and the sublime abyss of numbness, humankind’s attention has been malformed—detached and desensitized to itself and its surroundings.

Like the Church, some scientists and advocates of science have attempted to treat existential anxiety by constructing a new, unifying cosmology which envisions the integration of humanity in the natural world, not according to religious dicta, but according to scientific theories like evolution or geological frameworks like the Anthropocene, the anthropogenic geological era of which the advent of humans and human intervention are the primary markers. Proponents of these cosmologies seek to expand and renew interest in “the magic of reality,” cultivating a kind of wonder in the natural world and humanity’s role in this or the coming epoch.[6]

Lisa Sideris has observed how uncritical assumptions, or “mythmaking,” about human activity in these cosmologies has lent to the sciences and scientific endeavors a kind of sacrality.[7] By replacing one kind of enchantment for another, or rather by replacing enchanted fiction with enchanted fact, these science-inflected proposals try to reclaim lost significance, meaning, and purpose for the natural world and for humanity. In place of traditional religious narratives, they offer a secular and technocratic vision of humanity, grounded in a scientific “alternative mythology.” Thinkers as diverse as Thomas Berry and Richard Dawkins invest science with a mythological character by using language like the “epic of evolution,” the “Big Story,” “Universe Story,” or “Big History,”[8] and others.[9]

And yet, what kind of human subject do these scientific mythologies form? However much they create a kind of self-referential wonder they fail to bind the human person into a lived, intimate, and participatory relation with the world. They expand the scope of human significance, but evacuate the conditions of belonging. Sideris’s analysis and argument distinguishes between an abstract, uncritical, sentimentalized, and unintentional anthropocentrism coming from scientific (and pseudo-scientific) quarters, and a different kind of human centrality that she advocates, namely the centrality for humans of sensorial, embodied, and affective engagement with the natural world.

Like Sideris, Pope Francis may be understood as having reconstrued anthropocentrism and in the process distinguishing one kind of centrality from another, a good anthropocentrism from a bad one. For instance, human life is subject to an order that provides meaning, “How wonderful is the certainty that each human life is not adrift in the midst of hopeless chaos, in a world ruled by pure chance or endlessly recurring cycles!”[10] Rather, the human person in the natural world possesses an “infinite dignity.”[11] This dignity and distinction imparts centrality to the human, not to the detriment of the natural order, or even as an enchanted rise to the top of the cosmological ladder through human intervention,[12] but rather through humble relationships of fostering and nurturing.[13]

What are we to make of the confusion around the role of human beings in the natural world and critiques of anthropocentrism? While it is essential that the Church confront the degradation of the natural world, it is also the job of the Church and her theologians to work to address the isolation, dislocation, and hopelessness of humans.

II. A Primacy of Service: A New Stage of Anglican and Catholic Rapprochement

1. Anglican & Roman Catholic Dialogue in the Twenty-first Century

In 2015, while addressing members of ARCIC, Pope Francis said, “Today the world urgently needs the common, joyful witness of Christians, from the defense of life and human dignity to the promotion of justice and peace.”[14] A decade later, the two communions still face ongoing crises within their ranks and in the contexts in which they find themselves. In light of these crises, Pope Francis’s words are an exhortation to Anglican and Catholic Christians to “common, joyful witness” in all areas as an important part of ecumenical labor. Both primates stressed the vital importance of unity in witness and service.[15] Both also stressed that the Christian life is one of “walking together,” a theme which then was adopted by ARCIC for the first agreed statement, published two years later, on July 2, 2018.

Walking Together on the Way: Learning to Be Church—Local, Regional, and Universal, the joint statement of the Third Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commission, is a surprising document, advocating not only unified action in hitherto unheard-of ways, but also recommending a reciprocity and complementarity that far surpasses any prior ecumenical exchanges between Anglicans and Roman Catholics.[16] This new, or newly defined model of mutual dialogue, “receptive learning,” or “receptive ecumenism,” draws inspiration from previous ARCIC dialogue and ecclesial statements, including papal encyclicals and the preaching of recent popes and the Archbishop of Canterbury (15).[17] Walking Together invites the two communions to re-envision ecumenism as part of a self-reflective practice whereby each church mutually draws upon “elements” of the other’s tradition in order to further “the mission of the church in one’s own tradition” (iii). This is not merely procedural openness; it depends upon the cultivation of disciplined and charitable attention, marked by restraint of judgment, patience in receiving the other, and a willingness to be taught, and real courage in the face of difference. Receptivity simultaneously grounds and forms human attention in particularity and intimate knowledge of an other. The authors argue that a “critical self-examination through the prism of ecumenical dialogue and receptive learning can deepen the renewal and participation of the Church in the Trinitarian communion of God” (19).

The format alone of Walking Together is unique. The report proceeds by giving a frank assessment of both traditions. The authors see each communion as offering aid to the other as “pilgrim companions” (iv). Since its inception, the primary directive of ARCIC has been “the restoration of complete communion in faith and sacramental life,” and “visible unity and full ecclesial communion” (1). Walking Together, however, received a second mandate: “the discernment of right ethical teaching” (5).

In contrast to the initial goal of full communion, this second mandate grants ecumenical dialogue a fresh relevance by directing the goods of ecumenism outward. Unity is important for capturing “a common voice in the public square” (3), for relying on shared gifts in order to discern ways to speak to the world together. While such common address to the world is always missiological, it is important to note that this common voice need not be an apologetic one, defending the cause for faith. Rather, the authors envision a humble, thankful, and charitable exploration that itself constitutes and will lead to further constructive witness to our shared form of Christian life (21).

2. Receptive Learning & Ecumenical Unity in Practice

The ecumenical movement in our century . . . has been characterized by a missionary outlook.
—John Paul II, Ut unum sint §98

The relevance and distinctiveness of this third phase of dialogue is manifest in the history of Anglican and Roman Catholic Dialogue. Indeed, Anglicans have been invested in institutional ecumenism as long as there has been institutional ecumenism.[18] As Paul Avis observes, Anglican commitment to ecumenism was animated first by a concern for Christian missions rather than a concern for full communion. The call for missional unity, and an anxiety that disunity led to a loss of credibility, drove the cause for interdenominational unity.

The Chicago-Lambeth quadrilateral (1886), initially a doctrinal declaration by the Bishops of the Episcopal Church, emerged from efforts in the 1870s to heal Christian schism and promote Christian unity for the sake of global missions.[19] Before outlining the fundamental tenets, however, the bishops enumerated four core ecumenical commitments: reunion, trinitarian baptism, unity in essentials and liberty in non-essentials, and healing schism through cooperation not absorption.

By the next century, the need for unity was even more pronounced. In 1921, Roman Catholics and Anglicans began the Malines Conversations. While the content of the Malines dialogues was not about unity-in-practice but rather unity-in-doctrine, the approach to doctrinal unity allowed a previously unheard of amount of doctrine diversity. Although Malines was abruptly concluded in 1927, Paul Avis rightly notes that they “established the tone for later initiatives of rapprochement.”[20]

The spirit that marked Malines gave rise to the conciliar movement of the mid-twentieth century and the return (institutionally) of Roman Catholic enthusiasm for ecumenical dialogue, and, most significantly, the historic meeting of Pope Paul VI and Archbishop of Canterbury Michael Ramsey in Rome on March 24, 1966. In turn, their meeting was followed by the Malta Report (1968), which commended two stages of rapprochement.[21] The first entailed discovery of commonality and a process of letting go of Reformation patrimony in both Anglicanism and Roman Catholicism.[22] The authors proffered that differences stem “not so much from the substance of [their shared] inheritance as from our separate ways of receiving it.”[23] “Receiving” the inheritance of Western Christianity, however, is no small matter. And so, the authors call for a second stage in which differences of interpretation, understanding, and teaching of the faith would be explored by an international commission, ARCIC.

3. Possibilities for Unity in Mission & Practice

Walking Together represents an unprecedented ecumenical and practical appraisal of discipleship writ large, not only by evaluating practical instruments of decision making in each Church, but also by giving special attention to how these instruments may be shared and received by each other (11).[24] The spirit of John Paul II’s commendation of ecumenism as an exchange of gifts and, particularly, his understanding of papal primacy as a primacy of service is clearly recognizable in this exhortation.[25] The change is that Walking Together does all this according to receptivity.

One of the great strengths here is the formation of a shared attention and dialogical practice, ordered not neutrally but toward truth. The focal point in receptivity is the other as given rather than something to master or reduce. Encountering another tradition in receptive dialogue means careful observation of difference and complementarity. In this way, ecumenical practice becomes a discipline that forms how Christians attend to one another, to tradition, and ultimately to reality itself.

Walking Together’s main focus is on decision-making structures. The model of receptivity, however, can be applied to other matters, such as theological teaching. In fact, receptivity offers a potentially salient means by which the Anglican and Roman traditions might engage each other to the end of strengthening their own engagement with science-related issues like the role of the human in the natural world.

4. Different Ways of Engaging the Sciences

A distinguishing aspect of Roman Catholic engagement with the sciences is a cohesive institutional support structure and sustained theological reflection. Exemplifying this institutional commitment, the Vatican Observatory (formally re-established in 1891) is the result of papal support for astronomy as early as the sixteenth century.[26] Papal teaching, most notably in encyclicals and numerous pastoral letters by John Paul II,[27] has not only articulated theological support for scientific work, but also stressed the need for a receptive disposition.

Pope John Paul II stressed this disposition explicitly in his letter to George Coyne, SJ: “Each can draw the other into a wider world, a world in which both can flourish.”[28] Theological engagement with the sciences requires an openness to scientific discoveries and their significance for the human person. Such dialogue, as Fides et Ratio suggests, is integral to the Church’s defense of human dignity.

Papal engagement with the sciences has also addressed ecological vulnerability. In Laudato Si’, Pope Francis brought scientific knowledge of environmental degradation into conversation with Catholic social teaching, calling humanity to a shared responsibility for creation. His approach developed concerns already evident in Benedict XVI’s Caritas in Veritate, particularly the ethical dimensions of environmental responsibility.[29]

Likewise, Anglican theological reflection has fostered a rich and thoughtful scientific heritage, drawing on patristic, scholastic, and modern theological thinking to engage scientific issues. However, English intellectual culture is the result, in part, of the historic entanglement of the Church of England and global Communion with British culture. Today, the Anglican Communion engages the sciences through a unique dispersed interaction of social, scientific, university, and ecclesiastical bodies. University contributions such as Durham University’s Equipping Christian Leadership in an Age of Science are notable for emphases to integrate scientific inquiry with philosophical and theological thinking. More recently, the creation of the Anglican Communion Science Commission in 2022 establishes a global network of scientific reflection that draws on and nurtures regional expertise.[30]

Similarly, Anglican ecclesial commitments have given rise to reflection on ecological crises. The fifth mark of Mission, added in 1990, affirms the Anglican Communion’s commitment “to safeguard the integrity of creation, and sustain and renew the life of the earth.”[31] During his time as Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams spoke directly to Parliament about the need as a society to have clearly developed moral guidelines, supported by an equally clear notion of the human person, when dealing with scientific and medical developments.[32]

How might receptive ecumenism increase theological engagement with the sciences? Anglicans might receive from Roman Catholic practice a model of sustained institutional support for scientific inquiry, together with theological reflection articulated through papal teaching. Likewise, Roman Catholics might receive from Anglican practice an emerging model of scientific engagement that draws upon geographically diverse communities and their particular concerns. Bodies such as the Anglican Communion Science Commission and its wider networks could collaborate with Roman Catholic research institutions, universities, and theological initiatives. Collaborations such as these would express receptive learning through shared activity, rather than simply through appreciation. The possibility of common reflection and inquiry, however, returns us to our initial question of anthropocentrism: what of the vocation of the human being who undertakes such work?

III. The Need for a Rich Theological Anthropology in Conversation with the Sciences

The question of human vocation is not simply an ethical and epistemological one, but rather one about the formation of a person who can rightly perceive and live in the world. Christian theologians in the twentieth century have already developed rich accounts of that formation, much of which is a retrieval of patristic and medieval sources. However, these retrievals have yet to be brought to bear in sustained ways in dialogue with the sciences.

One obstacle to forging this conversation is premature criticisms of the theological anthropology of the last two millennia, which critics routinely dismiss as anthropocentric.[33] These dismissals point regularly to perceived anthropocentrism in Scripture, Christian tradition, and theology, but tend to overlook resources that are already in the tradition for addressing contemporary concerns. Ironically, in so doing, such criticisms often fail to see pervasive anthropocentrism in many of the scientific proposals for which they are enthusiastic.[34]

The account of the human person in the cosmos as a steward is perhaps best captured in the fact that both the Roman Catholic Missal and the 1979 Episcopal Book of Common Prayer include adapted forms of the Eucharistic Prayer of St. Basil. Eucharistic prayer D in the 1979 American Book of Common Prayer (BCP) says,

You formed us in your own image, giving the whole world into our care, so that, in obedience to you, our Creator, we might rule and serve all your creatures. When our disobedience took us far from you, you did not abandon us to the power of death.

Similarly, the Roman Missal’s Eucharistic Prayer IV says,

You formed man in your own image and entrusted the whole world to his care, so that in serving you alone, the Creator, he might have dominion over all creatures. And when through disobedience he had lost your friendship, you did not abandon him to the domain of death.

The prayers’ shared language of dominion and ruling is contextualized first by the creation of humankind in the divine image, and second by responsibility of trust (Missal) and care (Missal & BCP). The two Prayers diverge on the matter of service: the Missal indicates that humans were created to serve God alone, by which they were given dominion over creatures, whereas the BCP indicates that humans were created to both rule and serve creatures. Read within the original context of “care,” however, it is reasonable to understand the special dominion of humanity over creation, in both adaptations, as one of nurture.

The Prayer continues, narrating how human disobedience disrupted the initial harmony of care and dominion, but did not result in God abandoning his children. God called to his people through the covenants and prophets, instilling in them a desire for salvation.

In both canons, the Incarnation, Passion, and Resurrection are presented as remedies for the disobedience of humanity and its pernicious effects. However, it is the end of this section of the Prayer in both versions that is most important for our purposes. The whole event of the Incarnation, Passion, Resurrection, Ascension, and founding of the Church in the gift of the Holy Spirit is presented as a paradigm shift for human vocation.

Prayer D:

And, that we might live no longer for ourselves, but for him who died and rose for us, he sent the Holy Spirit, his own first gift for those who believe, to complete his work in the world, and to bring to fulfillment the sanctification of all.

Prayer IV:

And that we might live no longer for ourselves but for him who died and rose again for us, he sent the Holy Spirit from you, Father, as the first fruits for those who believe, so that, bringing to perfection his work in the world, he might sanctify creation to the full.

The Holy Spirit enables what we might describe as a re-creation of the human race, people whose vocation is not only care and obedience, but self-sacrificial living. Both the Missal and the BCP describe the ramifications of Christ’s work on creation. The BCP indicates that creation is made new, whereas the Missal describes the sanctification of “creation to the full.” That difference aside, however, the point is clear that human service as a lived, embodied, and particular thing (“for those who believe, to complete” [BCP]; “first fruits for those who believe, so that, bring to perfection” [Missal]) will participate in and receive the sanctification of the Holy Spirit.

It is significant that both Roman Catholics and Anglicans have situated this narrative arc of creation, break, sacrifice, and re-creation within their Eucharistic liturgies.[35] As Rowan Williams has argued, the eucharist carries out this recreation by re-forming our relationship to God as one of seeing or attention, after which our relationship to creation is renewed. “First see what is there. ‘What seest thou else?’ Well, that seeing which is required of the ordained minister, required of all the baptized, that is part of what is required of living eucharistically. That seeing of our environment as related first to God before it is related to me. First related to the Giver, even before I experience it as a gift.”[36]

In this sense, Eucharistic participation may be understood as attunement to the gift of creation—forming the human person to receive and respond to what is given. Eucharistic seeing enables a different kind of living and being embodied in the cosmos as our vision of the cosmos, ourselves, and our neighbors is re-grounded in being remade by Christ through the Holy Spirit. For our purposes, the language of creation in the Eucharistic canon is significant because, as Williams indicates, in the Eucharist we discover humanity’s new vocation.[37] Re-created, eucharistic humanity is marked by the dynamic transformation from disobedient and fallen rulers over creation into humble servants, recreated and renewed through the Holy Spirit in the image of their Ruler, Christ the Lord.

Yes, humans are recalled to the original vocation of steward, and the dominion it entailed. In re-creation, however, they are called beyond that to something new. Being remade in the image of Christ through Eucharistic participation conveys a mandate shaped by service in a deeper way than that given in Eden. This new vocation of re-creation grounds the experience of being human both ethically and affectively in bonds of humility and service such that it is not merely duty but also mutual affection and love that characterize the new humanity. In the world being made new by Christ, humans exercise primacy amongst their fellow creatures as servants, not lords. Or, to press the Christological point further, lordship is recast as service as humans are reformed as Christ-like servants. As the Rev’d Fred Rogers once observed, “Being a real king mean[s] being a slave first.”[38]

Theological anthropology in a Trinitarian key, far from reinforcing anthropocentrism, de-centers the human, casting the human being as a Christlike servant. Service is not an externalized ethical demand, but the very mode by which human beings inhabit their place within the created order. In this way, humans themselves are microcosms of the macrocosm. As microcosm, the human soul (or mind) and body flourish in a mutually nourishing relationship of supportive activity. So too, as macrocosm, the human and the natural world are called, together but differently, to support the other toward their mutual flourishing. The natural world provides a habitat, stable and accommodating, for humans and other organic life. And no less theologically poignant, the natural world provides the elements that are drawn up eucharistically into participation in the life of God. The human, nourished by the quotidian and eucharistic gifts of the earth, is called to exercise its powers, physical and intellectual, as servant and steward for the flourishing of the natural world.

If scientific inquiry expands our understanding of the world, liturgical formation shapes the kind of human who can inhabit that world rightly. Without such formation, human centrality can tend toward distorted anthropocentrism—either hegemonic domination or mythical abstraction. Reformed by eucharistic seeing, however, human life is reconstituted as participatory, attentive, and ordered toward service.

Conclusion

Christian theology has received a great deal of criticism for being anthropocentric, disintegrated, and not attentive to the current ecological situation. While some of these criticisms are warranted, certain attempts to reconstruct Christian theology through evolutionary cosmologies risk reproducing the very anthropocentrism they seek to overcome.

Christian theology has long possessed the resources for a theological anthropology that resists inherently destructive concepts of human centrality. That theological anthropology, however, has yet to be fully brought into conversation with the sciences. Receptive ecumenism, as described by Walking Together, makes visible a shared liturgical anthropology that can help address the ethical and anthropological problems surrounding scientific activity. Taken together, Anglican and Roman Catholic eucharistic liturgies envision a human vocation of not mere harmony with God and creation, but the actualization of human identity in service to God and creation. The task, then, is not necessarily more refinement or critique of theological anthropology, but rather to attend to the critical practices that form human perception, desire, and action.

Eucharistic seeing offers an ethical and contemplative foundation to the work of scientists. Indeed, eucharistic reordering is a matter of attention and belonging. As attention, eucharistic perception contemplates creatures, not as possession, but as gifts that receive, in different ways, the work of grace. As belonging, eucharistic participation reorders human activity in ways resistant to sentimental, ascending, and nostalgic notions of human progress and accomplishment, instead presenting human beings as agents of care, cooperation, and service. In this way, Eucharistic seeing helps form a vital, participatory human subject who is capable of the patient, attentive, ethical inquiry from which the sciences so benefit.

Indeed, far from resisting science, eucharistic perception cultivates the dispositions that direct science toward flourishing, responsibility, cooperation, and even wonder at the limits of science itself. A science ordered toward these ends, while remaining faithful to its own ends, is a science receptively open to contributions beyond itself. Theology’s account of human vocation can illuminate the ends of scientific activity. And receptivity calls for a mutual openness, according to which scientific activity can call forth not only a greater and more patient attention to the concrete and embodied in theological inquiry, but a deeper attention to and reception of the natural world in theology’s conception of creaturely being and sanctification. “[C]an we not hope,” as John Paul II asked George Coyne, “that the sciences of today . . . may invigorate and inform those parts of the theological enterprise that bear on the relation of nature, humanity, and God?”[39]


[1] For helpful introductions and context, see Christopher Southgate’s The Groaning of Creation: God, Evolution, and the Problem of Evil (Westminster John Knox, 2008), David Clough’s On Animals, Vol. 1: Systematic Theology (T&T Clark, 2012), John O’Keefe’s “Pope Benedict’s Anthropocentrism: Is it a Deal Breaker?” in Journal of Religion and Society (2013, supplement): 85–93, Ryan McLaughlin, Christian Theology and the Status of Animals: The Dominant Tradition and Its Alternatives (Palgrave, 2014), and Elizabeth Johnson’s Ask the Beasts: Darwin and the God of Love (Bloomsbury, 2014).

[2] Laudato Si’ is itself a constructive account of human vocation. See Vincent Miller, The Theological and Ecological Vision of Laudato Si’ (Bloomsbury, 2017).

[3] The Anglican Roman Catholic International Commission, Walking Together on the Way: Learning to be the Church – Local, Regional, Universal (July 2, 2018), iarccum.org/doc/?d=721. Hereafter Walking Together.

[4] Gaudium et Spes §6.

[5] Percy, The Moviegoer (emphasis mine).

[6] Richard Dawkins, The Magic of Reality: How We Know What’s Really True (Free Press, 2012).

[7] Lisa Sideris, “Forum Response: The Confines of Consecration: A Reply to Critics,” in the Journal for the Study of Religion, Nature, and Culture 9 (2015): 221, and Consecrating Science: Wonder, Knowledge, and the Natural World (University of California Press, 2017).

[8] Michael Dowd, ‘The Evidential Reformation: Humanity Comes of Age,” HuffingtonPost, April 17, 2012. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/rev-michael-dowd/the-evidential-reformation-humanity-comes-of-age_b_1421966.html.

[9] Sideris, Consecrating Science, 6 and 9. Sideris argues that these alternative mythologies or stories promote anthropocentrism unintentionally, either by their uncritical narratives of ascent to the Anthropocene or their elevation of human wonder. Moreover, the stories do not always support the non-human creature values that the authors purport to embrace. Finally, she argues that these authors ascribe to the alternative stories with a hagiographical devotion that fosters uncritical attitudes toward the stories themselves and the way they are deployed.

[10] Laudato Si’ §65.

[11] Laudato Si’ §65, quoting Pope John Paul II, Angelus in Osnabrück (Germany) with the disabled, 16 November 1980: Insegnamenti 3/2 (1980), 1232.

[12] Francis was wary about interventionism; see Laudato Si’, §34.

[13] Laudato Si’ §86, quoting the Catechism of the Catholic Church §340: “Creatures exist only in dependence on each other, to complete each other, in the service of each other.”

[14] Pope Francis, “Address of his Holiness Pope Francis to Members of the Anglican Roman Catholic International Commission” (The Holy See: April 30, 2015). https://w2.vatican.va/content/francesco/en/speeches/2015/april/documents/papa-francesco_20150430_commissione-internazionale-anglicana-cattolica.html

[15] Archbishop Justin Welby, “Homily of Archbishop Justin Welby at San Gregorio al Celio,“ 5 Oct. 2016 (https://iarccum.org/doc/?d=1253). Pope Francis, “Address of His Holiness Pope Francis to His Grace the Archbishop of Canterbury and the Primates of the Anglican Communion,” 6 Oct. 2016 (https://iarccum.org/doc/?d=1255).

[16] Walking Together §8. Hereafter, sections will be cited parenthetically.

[17] Citing Ut Unum Sint §28. Both Pope John Paul the Great’s Ut Unum Sint, and his emphasis on the “sharing of gifts,” as well as Pope Francis’s sermons and encyclical Evangelii Gaudium, for instance, are cited as generative loci.

[18] Paul Avis, “Anglicanism and Christian Unity in the Twentieth Century,” in The Oxford History of Anglicanism, vol. IV: Global Western Anglicanism, c. 1910–Present, ed. Jeremy Morris (Oxford, 2017), 187.

[19] See Resolution of the General Convention, 1886: Journal of the Proceedings of the Bishops, Clergy, and Laity of the Protestant Episcopal Church in the USA, Chicago, 1886 (Printed for the Convention 1887): 78–80.

[20] Avis, “Anglicanism and Christian Unity in the Twentieth Century,” 207. See Pope Pius XI’s encyclical Mortalium Animos (1928), http://w2.vatican.va/content/pius-xi/en/encyclicals/documents/hf_p-xi_enc_19280106_mortalium-animos.html.

[21] This meeting was a harbinger of “a new stage in relations” between the Anglican Communion and the Roman Catholic Church. See Anglican-Roman Catholic Preparatory Commission, “The Malta Report,” in Alan C. Clark & Colin Davey (eds.), Anglican/Roman Catholic Dialogue: The Work of the Preparatory Commission (Oxford University Press, 1974), 107-115, reprinted in Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commission, The Final Report (CTS/SPCK, 1982), 108-116.

[22] “The Malta Report” §4.

[23] The first phases of ARCIC (1970–81 & 1983–2005) concluded with final statements issued in 1981 and 2016. The third phase, 2011–2026, issued Walking Together in July of 2018, and announced the conclusion of the final phase and future publication of the final document, While They Were Talking and Discussing: Learning to Do Moral Discernment in Communion, on Oct 5, 2026. See ARCIC, “Communiqué,” Oct 5, 2026 (https://media.anglicancommunion.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/19160109/ARCIC-III-Communique-October-2026-FINAL3.pdf). Together, these documents aim to address the totality of the Christian life, and how ecumenical unity can support Christians in their witness to the world.

[24] An earlier document, Growing Together in Unity and Mission: An Agreed Statement
by the International Anglican—Roman Catholic Commission for Unity and Mission (2/4/2007), helped to set the tone for the receptive learning of Walking Together.

[25] St. John Paul II, Ut Unum Sint. See §28, citing Pope Paul VI, Ecclesiam Suam: “Dialogue is not simply an exchange of ideas. In some way it is always an ‘exchange of gifts.’”

[26] Most notable is the completion and use of the Gregorian Tower, or Tower of the Winds, in 1580. See http://www.archiviosegretovaticano.va/content/archiviosegretovaticano/en/l_archivio/ambienti/torre-dei-venti.html. Of course, Roman Catholic scholars have undertaken scientific research in every era of the Church.

[27] See esp. Fides et Ratio §4, and “Letter of his Holiness John Paul II to Reverend George V. Coyne, S.J., Director of the Vatican Observatory,” 1988 (http://w2.vatican.va/content/john-paul-ii/en/letters/1988/documents/hf_jp-ii_let_19880601_padre-coyne.html).

[28] John Paul II, “Letter to George V. Coyne,” 1988: “Science can purify religion from error and superstition; religion can purify science from idolatry and false absolutes. Each can draw the other into a wider world, a world in which both can flourish.”

[29] See John O’Keefe, “Pope Benedict’s Anthropocentrism: Is It A Deal Breaker?” in Journal of Religion and Society, Supplement 9 (2013): 89–90. O’Keefe sees Benedict’s teaching on the environment as a development of John Paul II’s encyclical Sollicitudo rei Socialis.

[30] Durham University launched “Equipping Christian Leadership in an Age of Science” in 2015. Funded by the Templeton World Charity Fund and the Church of England, Durham’s program resembles that of another Templeton-funded project, the Religion and Science Initiative of the McGrath Institute for Church Life at the University of Notre Dame.

[32] Jonathan Wynne-Jones, “Rowan Williams: Society Can’t Handle Science,” Telegraph 3/15/08 (https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1581762/Rowan-Williams-Society-cant-handle-science.html). See also his public debate with Richard Dawkins on Feb. 23, 2012 at Sophia Europa (the Theology Faculty), Oxford University.

[33] See Lynn White, Jr., “The Historical Roots of our Ecological Crisis,” Science 155 (March 1967): 1203–1207; David Clough, On Animals, vol. I, xx; Ilia Delio, “Theology needs radical revisioning,“ Global Sisters Report (July 1, 2019): https://www.globalsistersreport.org/column/spirituality-environment/theology-needs-radical-revisioning-56295). This is a recurring argument from Elizabeth Johnson. See her quote above.

[34] Ilia Delio, “Theology needs radical revisioning.” Delio argues that, “We are in movement, which means everything of God, including creation, human personhood, social justice, everything, must be considered from the point of movement.” She pleas for an “integrative vision of science and theology,” in which theology is reformed according to the “new” perspective of “movement . . . complex dynamical systems, cybernetics, and information.” She concludes, “What would an open systems theology look like instead of 19th- and 20th-century systematics? What would a complex dynamic ecclesiological system look like instead of 20th-century ecclesiology?”

[35] Pace Elizabeth Johnson’s implication that liturgical theology and the present form of the liturgy neglects creaturely relationships, an interesting claim to make three years after the publication of Laudato Si’. See http://www.bcgavel.com/2019/03/16/theologian-elizabeth-johnson-calls-on-the-church-to-address-a-planet-in-peril/.

[36] Rowan Williams, “Sacramental Living,” Trinity Papers 32, Trinity College, the University of Melbourne (May 2002), 18.

[37] Compare with International Theological Commission’s statement, Communion and Stewardship: Human Persons Created in the Image of God (Vatican, 2004), §79–80.

[38] Fred Rogers, “Sermon for the Installation of the Reverend Kenneth L. Barley,” Jan. 15, 1989 (from the Fred Rogers Archive, Latrobe, PA).

[39] John Paul II, “Letter to George Coyne”

Church Life Journal | Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.