September 1, 2024–Beyond “Good Guy vs. Bad Guy”
Jacqui Buschor, Little Rock, AR
Warm-up Questions
- Do you like games where people compete against each other like Monopoly, or games where everyone works together toward a common goal, like escape rooms?
- Why do you think that is your preference?
Whose Side Are You On, Anyway?
Even if you’re not old enough to vote, I’m sure you’ve heard people talking about “the growing political divide in America.” Maybe you’ve seen evidence of it yourself on the news, in your church, or even in your own family. It seems like everywhere we turn we can find more and more evidence that people are less and less able to listen to each other, especially about politics. Sometimes it feels like the only thing anyone can agree on is how impossible it would be for us to agree. It can be pretty stressful to watch.
But what if our political divide isn’t as huge or even as real as it seems? A recent article in Time Magazine paints a very different story of our country. It explains that while a small number of people on both political sides are very divided, most average Americans actually agree a lot more than we disagree. Like, a lot more. Their survey discovered what they called “stunning agreement” on almost every single issue they asked about.
So why, if most Americans agree more than we disagree, does it seem like things are more divided than ever? Well, partly, because those small groups who are very divided are also very loud, so we hear them more often. But mostly, because of something called “learned divisiveness,” which basically means we think people are becoming more and more divided because someone told us that’s what’s happening, and because we’ve been told it’s happening, our brains collect evidence to support that story, even if it’s not entirely true.
Discussion Questions
- How have you felt when you heard people talking about “the growing political divide”?
- What might be possible for us if we realized we actually agreed more than we disagreed?
Fifteenth Sunday After Pentecost
Text links are to Oremus Bible Browser. Oremus Bible Browser is not affiliated with or supported by the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America. You can find the calendar of readings at Lectionary Readings.
For lectionary humor and insight, check the weekly comic Agnus Day.
Beyond “Good Guy vs. Bad Guy”
If you’ve heard a sermon about this week’s gospel before, I’d be willing to bet that sermon went something like this: The Jewish leaders were trying to trap Jesus and accuse him of not following God’s laws, but Jesus flipped the script and told them they were the wrong ones, rejecting them and their strict religious laws. This story, like many others, is often used to support the narrative that Jesus, obviously the good guy, is always fighting off the Jewish leaders like they’re the evil villains in some cheesy superhero movie.
This “Good Guy vs. Bad Guy” showdown might make for a great movie plot, but when we try to cast Jesus and the Jewish leaders in those roles, we forget one pretty important detail. Jesus was Jewish. For his whole life. There are lots of stories that demonstrate Jesus following Jewish laws and customs (attending temple, celebrating Jewish festivals, studying the Torah), but we won’t find one single story in the gospels that suggest Jesus was ever trying to start a whole new religion. Instead, over and over the bible tells us stories of Jesus speaking (sometimes harshly) to the leaders of his own Jewish faith, pushing them to stretch and grow their understanding of God and God’s hopes for the world, challenging them to practice a more just and compassionate expression of the same Jewish faith they all shared. Jesus wasn’t fighting against the Jewish leaders as much as trying to work with them to build the kind of world God dreams of for everyone.
We’ve often heard stories that seem to pit Jesus against “the Jews” like they were on opposite sides of an impossible divide, but as a Jewish teacher himself, Jesus shared a lot in common with the leaders he so often challenged. They all loved God, they respected God’s scriptures, and they all wanted a safe future for God’s people, even if they didn’t always agree on how to get there. Read the gospel story again, but this time try reading it remembering Jesus doesn’t see the Jewish leaders as enemies.
Discussion Questions
- Does reading the story this way change the way you hear Jesus’s challenge to the Jewish leaders? If so, how?
- What kind of church do you want to be a part of?
- What kinds of things do you want your church to stand for?
- What kinds of ministry would you like to see your church do in the world?
Activity Suggestions
- Conduct a survey of your own. Interview some people from your congregation about what kind of church they want to be a part of. Try to include people of different backgrounds or different generations.
- With your friends, discuss your results. Did you discover any surprising similarities or potential new allies? What new things might be possible if you joined forces with your new potential partners?
Closing prayer:
Loving God, In a world that often seems so divided, help us to remember that we are more alike than different. Help us to see your holy image in those around us, even when we disagree. Inspire us to find new ways to work together toward your dream of a world ruled by justice, peace, and love. In Jesus’ name we pray: Amen.
