Sacrament, Cinema, and a Samurai Saint: Notes on Filming the Japanese Tea Ceremony

The wind swept across the Sea of Japan, whistled down the walls of Kanazawa Castle, and rustled the azalea blooms in a corner of the Zen garden. Rain pattered against the clay roof of the tea house. Inside, the afternoon light diffused through the shoji paper doors and wove itself into the tatami mats. The scene could have been plucked straight from the sixteenth-century—but for the $ 100k movie camera whirring inside the tea house.

Our team of American and Japanese filmmakers were a week into a month-long shoot for a documentary about Blessed Justo Takayama Ukon (1551–1615). Ukon was a Christian convert and prominent warlord, or daimyo, during the Warring States Period of Japan (1467–1615) who, at the peak of his powers, chose to renounce his status rather than recant his faith. He was exiled in the northern region of Kanazawa, where he devoted himself to practicing chanoyu, the Way of Tea.

When you hear “samurai saint,” matcha is usually not the first image that leaps to mind. But Ukon was a lifelong student of chanoyu. One zealous Jesuit even called him “the foremost master” of the art. Ukon trained under one of the most famous tea masters in Japanese history, Sen no Rikyu (1522–1591), known today for giving the tea ceremony its modern form. In Ukon’s time, the ritual was a refined social practice. Elites would gather at lavish tea-tasting parties (tōcha) to show off their fine taste and expensive utensils. High-quality bowls, tea caddies, bamboo whisks, and scoops could fetch prices as high as katanas. Hidden behind shoji paper walls, daimyos would gather, caffeinate, and strike deals.

But more than that, chanoyu was integral to Ukon’s faith. He regularly invited daimyos to his chashitsu (tea house) to sip tea and speak about Christianity. After he was exiled to Kanazawa, the samurai often retreated onto the tatami mats to pray. The tearoom was his monastic cell for twenty-six years, until the reigning shogun outlawed Christianity, and Ukon and his family were sent to Manila, where he died two months after arrival.

Some four centuries later, our film crew boarded the bullet train north from Tokyo to Kanazawa. Our mission was simple: film the tea ceremony as Ukon would have practiced it. The ritual would stage a key emotional scene in our story. Our protagonist was Yoko, a former actress who had grown up in Kanazawa, but left for Tokyo after a difficult childhood. After more rocky years, she discovered Ukon’s story and converted to Christianity. Now, she was returning to Kanazawa for the first time in decades. A former student of chanoyu, she would celebrate the homecoming with tea.

Our host and mentor figure was Yuumi, a tea master and Ukon scholar, who wrote a book on chanoyu and the sixteenth-century Jesuit mission. As we envisioned it, the ritual would create a healing encounter at multiple levels: Yuumi and Ukon would welcome Yoko home, and Ukon would help everyone contemplate God through chanoyu, just as he did in the sixteenth century.

But on the ground, with our packed production schedule, we had only seven hours to shoot in the teahouse: 10am to 5pm. The circumstances did not make for easy contemplation. Ten o’clock on the day, our bus squeezed into the parking lot. The chashitsu was the most traditional we could find. High yellow walls, fine tatami floors, lush Zen Garden. It was owned by a prominent tea master of one of the schools that developed after Rikyu. We Americans trespassed nearly every social protocol in attempting to book the place for shooting. Our Japanese fixer pulled strings we did not even know existed to finalize the production plan. It was not cheap.

A group of elderly tea masters greeted us at the door. They smiled and bowed in white, two-toed socks (tabi) and pink kimonos. We took off our shoes and followed them down the narrow hallways, past several twists in the earth-smelling walls, to the 500-square-foot tearoom. The tatami mats were arranged like a woodblock puzzle around the sunken hearth. For the next five hours, we shuttled lights, reflectors, and dolly tracks from the van, blocking the windows, swapping lenses, adjusting the tripod. The tea masters bustled around, serving the crew mochi sweets and rice crackers. After a few hours, it looked like a hurricane had ripped through the tearoom: shoji walls stacked in a corner, gear bags splayed open, empty bento boxes stashed on chairs, drained green Oija tea bottles littered under the table with the damp socks.

But on camera, in the corner of the tearoom where Yoko and Yuumi knelt across from each other under the hot lights, the tearoom looked perfect. We added details to recreate the way Ukon designed his chashitsu: a red camellia flower, symbol of the martyrs, in a fresh green bamboo vase; a statue of “Maria-sama,” the Virgin Mary, in the alcove (tokonoma); over the hearth, in the center of the director’s monitor, a cast-iron tea kettle in the shape of a cross.

The details took time. When we were finally ready to roll, it was three o’clock. We had only two hours to shoot the whole ceremony. Even though the ritual for usucha (thin tea) can go as fast as fifteen minutes—koicha (thick tea) can take over three hours—we still had to shoot all the close-ups. It would be tight.

But tasked with keeping the schedule, I soon realized that the challenge went deeper than the time crunch. The room was filled with artists, and the way to perform the tea ceremony perfectly was directly at odds with the way to make it look perfect on camera.

The first art depends on flow—how the host lays the coal with chopsticks, pours the water, wipes the bowl, folds the cloth; when the guest enters, where she kneels, how she kneels, what direction she twists the tea bowl; every step precisely defined, down to the weave in the tatami mat; each call and response perfectly timed, uninterrupted. Interrupting, of course, is the only way filmmakers know how to make anything perfect.

“Action!” our director called.

Yuumi laid charcoals in the hearth with chopsticks. The cross-shaped kettle swung over the heat, full of water.

“AY!!” came a shout from somewhere off camera. A tea master leapt into the shot—eyes wide, both arms crossed in a violent “X”—Stop!

“Cut!”

The master swept across the mats, snatched Yuumi’s chopsticks, and moved the charcoals half an inch. Five minutes later, we were shooting again.

“Cut!”

We moved to the next scene. Our cameraman spent ten minutes adjusting lights. Yuumi took her new position.

“Action!”

The kitchen door slid open. Yuumi shuffled in, carrying the tray of utensils. She knelt on the mat in the traditional seiza posture, feet tucked under her legs, kimono tucked under her knees.

“Ay!” Another door snapped open from the hallway.

“Cut!”

The tea master, again, swept across the mats and tightened the waistbelt of Yuumi’s kimono. I could not keep my eyes off my watch. Five minutes later, we were rolling again.

“Action!”

Yuumi began cleaning the utensils. The sun moved from behind the clouds. The cameraman broke in to fix the exposure. Five minutes passed while he readjusted the reflectors. We rolled. Another tea master broke in to fix Yuumi’s technique for cleaning the bowl. We rolled again. Yuumi moved her hand in a different way from last take. The cameraman broke in to refocus the macro frame.

“Cut!” Another five minutes passed. “Action!”

The back-and-forth went on for an hour. Temperatures ran high. Yuumi’s knees cracked from getting up and down the mat in her kimono. Yoko hid her aches behind a smile. Everyone was buzzed with matcha. Our fixer asked the host to please stop interrupting. Our host nodded, then kept interrupting. Our fixer shrugged and smiled resignedly. It’s her tea house, she said without words, and you wanted to film the tea ceremony!

Somehow, it was four o’clock. We had finished neither the long take of the whole ceremony, nor any of the close-ups. One hour left. To get everything we needed, we had only one more shot to get the whole ritual uninterrupted.

“Action.”

Yuumi slid the door open. The cameraman moved back and forth on dolly tracks. All fourteen people in the tearoom held their breath. This time, in either the ceremony or the shoot, there could be no mistakes.

***

How did something so simple get so complicated? Sen no Rikyu’s original instructions for preparing matcha were just six rules. First, make a satisfying bowl of tea. Second, lay the charcoal so that the water boils efficiently. And so on. The point was to focus on the essentials: the encounter between host and guest. The task for us documentary filmmakers was supposed to be just as straightforward. Capture reality unscripted. Film Yoko drinking the tea. Point and shoot. Right?

And yet, four centuries after Rikyu, the demands of the ritual, and of cinematic production, had developed into the opposite of simple. Yuumi had to take several slaps on the wrist before her technique for boiling water was natural enough. We camerapeople had to block windows and chop the action into close-ups and long takes to reassemble everything in post—break the flow to show its “true form” in pixels. By the time we were rolling, there was nothing “natural” or “simple” in either the art we filmed or the art doing the filming. Where was our deep spiritual encounter in the thicket of all that technical perfection? What would Rikyu and Ukon think? Were we touching anything real?

For Rikyu, the heart of chanoyu lay in focusing on the basics. Following his lead, and Ukon’s, we can illuminate these difficulties by studying their aesthetic more closely—and clarifying what, exactly, we should understand by “natural.”

Rikyu came to prominence at the same moment that chanoyu was sliding into decadence. The most powerful daimyo in his time was Toyotomi Hideyoshi, who studied tea under Rikyu alongside Ukon. As he rose in power, Hideyoshi began to twist the spirit of the ceremony to serve his own ambitions. In 1587, shortly after he exiled Ukon to Kanazawa, Hideyoshi hosted an extravagant, multi-day tea gathering in Kyoto, where he invited thousands of guests to marvel at his wealth and drink tea in his solid gold tearoom. A replica of his chashitsu is still on display today at the Osaka Castle Museum. The gilded walls are so ferociously polished, you can see your reflection halfway down the hallway, even through the security glass.

Rikyu strove to recall chanoyu back from Hideyoshi’s corrupting influence, returning it to spiritual purity and poverty. Though the words originally had a different meaning, his aesthetic has come to be called “wabi-sabi.” Wabi-sabi cherishes natural, transient, and imperfect things. The coarsely textured tea bowl with an irregular lip. The fading sweetness of a decomposing leaf. The cracked, unpainted wood siding of a peasant home. A table made from discarded wood, polished by repeated use. Rikyu revered the beauty of whatever was humble, even broken or discarded. He found in such imperfections a higher perfection that no amount of gilding could reach. The essence of wabi-sabi lies in attuning ourselves to this mode of attention, where we recognize the value and poignancy of things simply for what they are.

There is a hidden complexity, though, in what wabi-sabi takes as “natural.” My normal, everyday mode of attention is more likely one of use, busyness, and goal-seeking than of quiet attention. When I go fishing, for example, I am too busy trying to catch dinner to ponder how beautifully the rust lies on the curve of the metal. Rikyu’s aesthetic demands that I take myself out of one mode of attention (use) and into a higher mode of attention, one more refined, composed, patient, and contemplative. Only under this gaze can natural things shine forth in their perfect imperfection. And this gaze might be natural, but it takes practice. It demands the mastery of a certain technique.

The same dynamic plays out in the refinement of human nature—how the person who practices wabi-sabi in his aesthetics develops a certain ethical character. The point is illustrated beautifully by another film about Ukon and chanoyu, Kinuyo Tanaka’s 1962 Love under the Crucifix. Based on a prize-winning novel, the movie follows Ukon’s romance with his (fictional) childhood sweetheart, Rikyu’s daughter Ogin. At one key moment, Rikyu describes how wabi-sabi is embodied not only in objects, but also, and especially, in the character of people. In the scene, Hideyoshi summons Rikyu to his courtroom, where he brags about his lavish tea gathering in Kyoto. Rikyu offers no praise for his former student. One of Hideyoshi’s consorts interprets this as an insult.

“Are you saying that having tea with lowly beggars in a thatched hut is a sign of pure heart,” she sneers, “but tea and gold amount to impurity and decadence?!”

Stone-faced, Rikyu replies: “Rather than a glorious flower in bloom, a weed blooming unknown amongst snow, is the true embodiment of spring, in my humble opinion.” He looks weary, then adds, “That is how the heart of one who truly loves tea must be. I cannot envision any alternative to that.”

Rikyu alludes, of course, to the man Hideyoshi has just banished to snowy Kanazawa: Ukon. Incensed, Hideyoshi storms out. Later, he gets revenge on Rikyu by making Ogin his concubine. Hideyoshi orders her to his golden tearoom, where he haughtily declares, “Whatever I want, I get.”

Rikyu’s contrast between Ukon and Hideyoshi illuminates the ethical dimensions of wabi-sabi. Both men share the same human nature, but Hideyoshi is “natural” in a low, untutored way. He indulges every impulse—greed, anger, lust, and pride. Ukon, in contrast, is refined. He is courageous in battle, meticulous in tea, temperate in court, contemplative in prayer, patient in exile. Ukon embodies nature cultivated, restrained, humbled, and above all, reverent toward its own limits, even (and especially) those limits set by forms and forces out of Ukon’s control, like social norms, ritual, and moral precepts. These are the forms that bound Ukon’s behavior, that shape his practices, that he respects with the same contemplative acceptance with which Rikyu looked at a cracked tea bowl. Therein lies Ukon’s excellence.

But—to return to the question of the Kanazawa tearoom—where lies Ukon’s perfection? What does wabi-sabi envision as the end-goal of his excellence? Following the forms for their own sake? Or do they, too, have limits? The answer depends on whether, and how, supernatural grace enters the picture.

Love under the Crucifix suggests that Ukon’s perfection lies wholly within nature. Late in the film, Ukon and Ogin are caught in a rainstorm and find shelter in a rustic hut, where they consummate their affair. (Conveniently, if un-historically, Ukon’s wife is dead at this point.) Later, Rikyu approves of their tryst as something totally natural. “If love has blossomed between childhood friends,” he says, “it is natural and human, qualities valued in the tea ceremony. I cannot blame them.” After Ukon returns to exile, Ogin decides to commit seppuku (ritual suicide) rather than live as Hideyoshi’s concubine. The film ends as she walks, contemplative and composed, into the room where she will slice open her stomach, as Rikyu (it is implied) kills himself offscreen.

The story arc is all natural—wabi-sabi in a moving picture. Ukon’s ethical refinement climaxes in a sexual union cut short by death. Childhood friends mature into love that meets natural limits. The film is tragically perfect in its human imperfection. What consolation the story cannot find in the lovers’ lasting union, it discovers in the fleeting beauty of ritual, nature, and art, intertwined as elegantly in seppuku as in chanoyu.

Sixteen years later, Kei Kumai remade the same story as the more historically accurate film, Love and Faith (1978), which gives a near-opposite vision of Ukon’s path to ethical perfection. In this story, after Ukon is exiled by Hideyoshi, Ogin finds the samurai alone in his bedroom. They fall into each other’s arms. (Ukon’s wife is still alive at this point.) Ukon carries Ogin to his bed. The next moment, he looks up and sees a crucifix hanging on his wall. Ukon stares. A beat passes. Then he stands up and asks Ogin to leave the room.

In contrast to Love Under the Crucifix, Ukon in Love and Faith upholds the natural order in one way and radically breaks with it, in another. He keeps his marriage vows. He denies himself sexual satisfaction with Ogin to preserve his temperance and fidelity to his wife. But what inspires that perseverance in natural virtue? The crucifix, the image of God-made-Man. Ukon’s affair with Ogin is left incomplete—not cut off by death, but interrupted by the Creator’s own breaking-into his creation. Ukon follows the natural ethical forms (demands of virtue) until they open into a new, supernatural horizon, the vision of which, paradoxically, helps him keep those natural forms intact: seeing Christ announces the limits of Ukon’s human marriage (it will be replaced by a higher union one day, that of Creator and creature), even as it helps Ukon keep his vows here and now, before that supernatural consummation. Ukon recognizes the limits of nature, but those limits look to a fulfillment greater than nature, in Christ, announced in-and-beyond his creation. It is striking that without this grace-filled rupture, both Hideyoshi and Rikyu (alongside his daughter) strive for antithetical visions of perfection, only to end in the same place: violence.

Is this Christological vision not a fuller development of wabi-sabi than one bounded wholly within the natural order? What could ultimately be more in keeping with Rikyu’s spirit than to recognize, and to accept, the limits of wabi-sabi itself—to see the finitude of nature not as absolute, but as itself limited, opening toward the horizon of fulfillment beyond nature? And what could be more natural than seeking the Source of nature himself, who has shared our broken nature to heal it with his grace?

From his life and its cinematic interpretations, Ukon gives wabi-sabi a new rhythm: follow the natural forms, recognize their limits, and let those forms be simultaneously, if paradoxically, broken open and perfected by grace—grace that, through Christ, reestablishes harmony between God and human persons, even if perfect communion between them is forestalled. Ukon followed this pattern in his historical witness to Christianity. As a servant of Hideyoshi, he followed the samurai code even at the moment he broke it, choosing loyalty to his heavenly lord above his earthly one. This renunciation participates in the same rhythm of the two rituals Ukon embodied in his exile: the tea ceremony and the Catholic Mass.

Both liturgies follow strict forms, developed from rustic beginnings, into increasing complexity. They begin with purifying rites. Priests and communicants confess. The tea host cleans utensils. Guests wash their hands and mouths. Then Scripture is read. A Zen scroll hangs in the alcove of the teahouse. Words and gestures are exchanged. A meal is prepared. The material elements matter—wine, bread, water, matcha powder. (Today, some tea hosts even burn incense over the charcoals.) At the climax of the rituals, after the rites have been perfectly executed, the host gives himself to the participants in the communion cup.

In chanoyu, the guest drinks the matcha. (As Yuumi explained, the tea host is believed to be present anywhere the scoop he fashioned is used. The logic is Eucharistic.) Afterwards, guest and host share unscripted, free-flowing conversation. The forms have opened the space for personal communion. Yet even this union is limited. Rikyu is often attributed with another saying in tea, ichi-go, ichi-e, loosely translated as “one encounter, one lifetime.” The idea is that even though chanoyu stays the same, you and I, guest and host, are always changing. Each time we meet, we are new people. We can only ever meet once, receiving together only our daily bread.

In the Mass, as in Ukon’s key scene from Love and Faith, this rhythm is swept into a supernatural dimension. The Presence in the communion meal is that not of the priest, but of God himself, who comes to the communicants in the panis fractura, broken bread. Even when the sacred host melts on the communicant’s tongue, his God remains hidden. The communion of persons is real, but is, here and now, just a foretaste of the perfect consummation awaiting beyond nature.

These parallels are not coincidental. Rikyu was interested in Ukon’s faith, though historians disagree on the extent of his influence. Some of Rikyu’s reforms even echo the Mass—guests drinking from one bowl, hosts wiping its lip with cloths. These resonances became palpable in the documentary, as we moved from the Kanazawa teahouse to shoot a Mass at Sophia University, observing the precision, reverence, and attention to detail of the priest and communicants. The historical and embodied connections between the two rituals, knit together by Ukon’s life, converge around an aesthetic and ethical unity: the perfection of natural forms, accepting their own limits, prepares the perfecter for grace that breaks into the encounter between persons.

***

These reflections go some way in illuminating our tea ceremony shoot. At their best, documentaries follow this same liturgical rhythm. Perfecting the form, for us, meant blocking windows, so the natural lightning looked cinematic; or breaking the flow of the ceremony, to get close-ups for post. This is how documentary filmmaking recognizes its limits. The French film critic André Bazin writes elegantly of the “myth of total cinema,”arguing that film, despite its aspirations, cannot capture all of reality. That is what excellence in the cinematic form requires.

Even still, in Kanazawa, the forms of both tea and filmmaking were broken into to make possible encounters between people. We interrupted the ceremony to get the right shots, so audiences could feel like they were in the chashitsu with Yoko, Yuumi, and Ukon, even if that feeling falls far short of total communion. The same was true for the documentary. Even after exhaustive pre-production, what happened onscreen came down to the free will of normal people. With an hour left in the shoot, Yoko and Yuumi were free to nail the ceremony or scuff it. They could have broken our vision of the film at any moment. It is this vulnerability to real people, and openness to being redirected by real life, that brings documentary filmmaking particularly close to wabi-sabi. Holding the fragments of life together, such a film, at its best, asks audiences to look at a person’s story with the eyes of God—with a contemplative, loving gaze of mercy. Seen in that light, the humble practice of such crafts, ever open to grace-filled interruptions, can become a means of living liturgically—of uniting our lives, as Ukon did, to Christ.

Yoko’s journey is a case in point. The documentary gave her a chance to revisit her difficult childhood in the presence of her friend, the samurai saint, and their shared Lord. Under the combined gazes—the camera, the saint, the Savior—the cracks in her story were made cruciform, like the shape of the kettle swinging over the charcoals Yuumi had so carefully laid.

***

Yoko’s smile seemed to say as much. It broke across her face under the honeycomb lights, at the end of a flawless take, when she sipped the matcha Yuumi had prepared. As the women leapt into conversation, I breathed for the first time in fifteen minutes.

I stepped into the Kanazawa teahouse expecting an intense shoot. I got that. But I also got a glimpse of grace—seeping through the cracks of limited art forms, and beautifully broken lives, knit together across centuries by the taste of green tea.

Then the cameraman sprang to his sock-feet to adjust the lights for close-ups. We could contemplate the rest in post.

Church Life Journal | Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.